Eureka Case 25 min Strategy

Where the Value Went

You are Ines Brenner, head of Vossberg Mess- und Regeltechnik, a EUR 720 million industrial-sensor maker in Stuttgart. Your largest customer of nineteen years has just left for a cheaper, less accurate sensor sold with a subscription. Before you divide a EUR 60 million envelope, you have to tell the board where the value in your industry is moving.

The situation

Vossberg, founded in 1962 and part of the Kirchner engineering group, makes sensors, flow meters and control equipment for chemical, food and water-treatment plants. It employs 3,100 people and closed 2025 with EUR 720 million of revenue and EUR 115 million of operating profit, a 16% margin. 84% of revenue comes from hardware: instruments sold once, installed for a decade and serviced under calibration contracts. Its gross margin is 38%, after losing two to three points a year for three years.

On 21 April 2026 you lost Rheinaue Wasserwerke: EUR 43 million a year, 6% of revenue and the reference account in every tender. It went to Talvi Systems, whose sensors are, by your own laboratory's measurements, less accurate and cheaper, but come with a subscription that tells the utility which pumps are about to fail. Firms like Talvi buy commodity sensors, sell them near cost and earn 60% to 75% gross margin on the analytics. Two more large accounts are evaluating the same competitor.

Group chief executive Georg Halbach has given you EUR 60 million for two years, two quarters to present the plan, and not a euro or a month more. Hanne Ostermann, who runs the sensor core, wants the money to take cost out of the instrument and sell more calibration. Marek Sattler of Digital Ventures (28 people, EUR 9 million a year, inside the hardware profit-and-loss account) wants it for the analytics layer. Your bonus moves with the hardware, and calibration is the business you built. Nothing forces your hand this year: orders are steady and the 16% will hold.

Your job in this case: look at the margins and the weight of each business, test how fast the hardware profit could erode, and commit to a reading of where the value is going. The whole EUR 60 million plan will be built on that reading.

The decision

Where is the value in Vossberg's industry moving?

  • A · Toward analytics and subscriptions
  • B · Toward calibration and field service
  • C · Not moving yet: the instrument still wins

The rest of the case is locked

The data, the calculations, the decision itself and what happens next open with your institution's access code.

Have an access code?

No code yet?

Instructors can request access for a course. Tell us who you are and which course it is for, and we will send your institution a code.

Run it live in class: every student decides and justifies, and the whole class sees how it splits. How Eureka Case works →