Eureka Case 25 min Economics

Three Asks, Thirty Billion

You are Ximena Arrieta-Valdés, Minister of Finance of the Republic of Costaria. The country is in recession, the central bank has almost no room left to cut, and this afternoon the Cabinet must decide how to spend a CO$30 billion rescue package. Three colleagues have asked for CO$48 billion between them. The first vote, on how the money is split, is at 15:30.

The situation

It is 15 September 2026. A fuel-price shock pushed inflation to 4.2% and then tipped Costaria into recession: output has fallen 2.8% in four quarters, the Treasury puts the output gap at −2.5%, and unemployment has risen from 5.5% to 8.7%. Inflation is back at 2.4% and consumer confidence is at a ten-year low. The central bank has cut its rate from 4.25% to 1.50%; its liaison in the room, deputy governor Bruno Lastra-Peña, reminds everyone how little room is left.

The package is about a tenth of a CO$290 billion economy, and most of it will be borrowed. Public debt is 62% of GDP, part of it in foreign currency, and government bonds yield 3.50%. The welfare system is already adding about CO$8 billion over two years without any vote. The Treasury's briefing lists six levers, each with a range for its multiplier (the output each CO$ generates in a deep recession), a typical delay and the groups who feel it first. Its draft puts CO$5 billion on each, and nobody at the table has argued for it.

Paula Senra-Ochoa, Minister of Infrastructure, wants at least CO$15 billion for roads, schools, energy retrofits and broadband that will outlast the recession. Óscar Villalba-Rey, Minister of Labour, wants CO$9 billion for benefits and CO$6 billion for retraining: the queue at his employment offices has doubled. Ignacio Prado-Lucena, Minister of the Economy and leader of the smaller coalition party, promised voters relief and wants CO$10 billion of income-tax cuts and CO$8 billion off VAT. Their requests add up to CO$48 billion.

Your job in this case: compare the six levers on more than one number, test how a split changes what the package buys and when it buys it, and decide whose request becomes the core of the CO$30 billion.

The decision

Whose request becomes the core of the CO$30 billion package?

  • A · Build: CO$15 billion for infrastructure
  • B · Protect: CO$15 billion for benefits and retraining
  • C · Relieve: CO$18 billion in income-tax and VAT cuts

The rest of the case is locked

The data, the calculations, the decision itself and what happens next open with your institution's access code.

Have an access code?

No code yet?

Instructors can request access for a course. Tell us who you are and which course it is for, and we will send your institution a code.

Run it live in class: every student decides and justifies, and the whole class sees how it splits. How Eureka Case works →