Eureka Case 25 min Risk Management

The Mark on the Wall

You are Francisca Morales Tapia, manager of Agrícola Coihuelén: 200 hectares of grain maize watered from a canal in Chimbarongo, in Chile's central valley. On Friday 10 July 2026 you present the season's plan to the family board, and the first question is which hybrid to sow for the next two seasons.

The situation

On Monday 6 July the canal association told you it expects to deliver about 85% of normal water this season. Jorge Muñoz, head of irrigation for twenty years, keeps the record: in the last ten seasons the canal reached its full allocation only twice, and in 2021-22 it delivered 45%. That year the traditional maize dried out in full flowering, and Jorge left a mark on the sluice wall, almost at the bottom.

With full water, the long-cycle traditional hybrid yields 13.5 tonnes per hectare. Maize sells for about $250,000 a tonne (Chilean pesos); sowing a hectare costs about $2.2 million, and the farm carries $50 million of fixed costs a season. In a normal year it earns about $185 million. It has $300 million in cash and a credit line for another $300 million, at 12% a season on any negative balance.

Semillas del Maule offers a two-season contract for a short-cycle hybrid that tolerates drought and heat. With full water it yields 12.2 tonnes, and its seed costs $0.10 million more per hectare. With 85% of the water the two hybrids yield almost the same, about 10.5 tonnes; with 45%, the traditional one falls to about 2.4 while the tolerant one holds near 6.8. In a very hot summer the traditional hybrid also loses considerably more than the tolerant one.

Patricio Soto, the accountant, ran the sum you asked for: if a season like 2021-22 came back with all 200 hectares in the traditional hybrid, the farm would lose about $372 million, more than all its cash. Your father, Hernán Morales, who planted the farm's first maize and chairs the board, has a different figure: in the good years, the traditional hybrid paid for the farm. He has already told you he wants to know whether the farm would hold up through four seasons worse than the last ten.

Your job in this case: look at how the canal has behaved, work out what the farm gains and loses with each hybrid mix depending on the water that arrives, and decide which mix you will propose to the board for the next two seasons.

The decision

Which hybrid mix do you sow for the 2026-27 and 2027-28 seasons?

  • A · All 200 ha in the traditional hybrid
  • B · Sow 40% of the area with the tolerant hybrid
  • C · Sow 80% of the area with the tolerant hybrid

The rest of the case is locked

The data, the calculations, the decision itself and what happens next open with your institution's access code.

Have an access code?

No code yet?

Instructors can request access for a course. Tell us who you are and which course it is for, and we will send your institution a code.

Run it live in class: every student decides and justifies, and the whole class sees how it splits. How Eureka Case works →