Eureka Case 25 min Finance

The Limit That Binds

You are Marisol Elizondo Vega, chief financial officer of Grupo Alimentos Bárcena, a family-owned food maker in Guadalajara, Mexico. You have three investments on your desk, MX$120 million in cash and eighteen days until the Family Council votes on your plan. Before you rank anything, your one-page baseline must say which limit will bind your plan hardest.

The situation

Don Esteban Bárcena founded the company in 1979: premium salsas, moles and ready meals for Mexican supermarket chains and, increasingly, the U.S. Hispanic market. Today it employs 1,150 people across plants in Guadalajara and Querétaro, and belongs to the second and third generations through a family holding, with a Family Council and a shareholders' agreement signed in 2024. In 2025 it posted revenue of MX$4,200 million on EBITDA of MX$588 million. Its cost of capital is about 13.5% a year in pesos.

The three proposals: a new line in Querétaro for MX$240 million, adding about MX$95 million of EBITDA a year; buying a co-packer in Texas for MX$180 million, the fastest route to serving a U.S. retailer's offer of a listing in 1,400 stores; and automating Guadalajara for MX$90 million, adding about MX$40 million of EBITDA a year at the lowest execution risk. Any investment above MX$200 million needs the full Council's approval.

Two rules frame any financing. Net debt is about 1.2 times EBITDA, and the agreement allows up to 2.5 times. And the MX$180 million dividend has been paid without a break for 46 years: one branch of the family, four cousins with no role in the business, lives on it and has let it be known it could force a buyout of its shares, estimated at about MX$900 million, if it is cut without their agreement. There are other sources too: a bank loan, a share placement with a non-family investor, or selling and leasing back the Guadalajara plant.

Your job in this case: look at the cash, the debt room and the family's numbers, test how far each rule really stretches, and decide which limit your baseline names as binding hardest. The Council will read every later proposal against it.

The decision

Which limit will bind your plan hardest?

  • A · The 2.5× covenant, which no plan can breach
  • B · Both together: the covenant and the dividend
  • C · The MX$180M dividend the family has never missed

The rest of the case is locked

The data, the calculations, the decision itself and what happens next open with your institution's access code.

Have an access code?

No code yet?

Instructors can request access for a course. Tell us who you are and which course it is for, and we will send your institution a code.

Run it live in class: every student decides and justifies, and the whole class sees how it splits. How Eureka Case works →