Eureka Case 25 min Operations

The Two Aluminium Quotes

You are Valeria Quiroga, director of operations and supply chain at Nutrisur Envases Industriales, a flexible-packaging maker in Córdoba, Argentina. It is Monday 9 March 2026. Next Monday the operations committee expects your first answer: where to buy the aluminium barrier film, and how many days of safety stock the plant should hold.

The situation

Nutrisur employs 680 people and turns over about ARS 98,400 million a year, at an 8.4% EBITDA margin. It buys 72% of its materials in dollars and sells 85% of its output in pesos. In the 2023 devaluation the peso lost 54% and the margin fell to 2.1%; the price increases that rebuilt it came four to five months late. The board wants the dollar share of material cost down to 50% in 24 months, with ARS 2,800 million for the whole redesign.

Aluminium film is 11% of materials and today it comes from China: $4,200 a ton, $380 of freight and insurance, a 120-day lead time and 0.8% defects. A Brazilian supplier quotes $5,100, 21% more, with $140 of freight, a 25-day lead time, lower management cost and 1.4% defects. Both invoice in dollars. Purchasing expects to buy about 250 tons over the next twelve months.

The plant holds 38 days of safety stock today. The largest customer, a national food group worth 18% of sales, ran out of packaging in 2024 when Chinese film arrived late, and this month it asked for a resilience plan for next year. The finance director, who controls the budget, sees every day of stock as cash tied up.

Your job in this case: compare the two quotes on everything they cost, not only the price; decide how much stock you need with each supplier, and choose the sourcing policy you will take to the committee.

The decision

How much aluminium do you buy from Brazil, and with how many days of stock?

  • A · Stay with China, raise stock to 45 days
  • B · Split: 40% to Brazil, 38 days for now
  • C · Move all to Brazil, cut stock to 20 days

The rest of the case is locked

The data, the calculations, the decision itself and what happens next open with your institution's access code.

Have an access code?

No code yet?

Instructors can request access for a course. Tell us who you are and which course it is for, and we will send your institution a code.

Run it live in class: every student decides and justifies, and the whole class sees how it splits. How Eureka Case works →