Eureka Case 30 min

The Fund's Letter

You are Rodrigo Vallcorba-Pizarro, 49, Director de Relación con Inversores at Energías de Iberia. Six weeks ago Cuatro Vientos Asset Management filed a say-on-climate proposal for the AGM. ISS and Glass Lewis have recommended FOR. Three European institutional investors have publicly aligned. The board meets in eleven days to set Energías de Iberia's response.

The situation

Energías de Iberia (EdI) is an IBEX-35 integrated utility — €42B market cap, 18 GW of generating capacity, 14M customers across Iberia and three LatAm markets. Climate plan published in 2023, refreshed 2025: 48% Scope 1+2 reduction by 2030 against 2020 baseline, net-zero by 2045. CA100+ benchmark scored EdI at 78% capex alignment with 1.5°C pathway in its 2025 review — top quartile for European utilities, not best-in-class.

Cuatro Vientos AM is a €3.2B Spanish boutique with a reputation for forcing climate-vote engagements with IBEX-35 issuers. Their proposal asks for four things: (1) lift the 2030 target to 60%; (2) publish a Scope 3 trajectory; (3) reach 90% CA100+ capex alignment by 2027; (4) link 30% of CEO long-term incentive to climate metrics (currently 12%). ISS and Glass Lewis both recommend FOR. Norges Bank (3.1% stake), APG (1.8%) and AP7 (0.9%) have publicly aligned. BlackRock (5.2%) and Vanguard (3.4%) are silent.

Your job in this case: read the shareholder-base sentiment, model the response shape that wins the vote (or moots it), and recommend the engagement posture to the board. The IR team has six weeks of road-show capacity left before the AGM. The CFO wants your memo by Tuesday.

The decision

What does EdI take to the board?

  • A · Hard reject — defend the plan
  • B · Partial accommodation — engage and revise
  • C · Embrace and remix

The rest of the case is locked

The data, the calculations, the decision itself and what happens next open with your institution's access code.

Have an access code?

No code yet?

Instructors can request access for a course. Tell us who you are and which course it is for, and we will send your institution a code.

Run it live in class: every student decides and justifies, and the whole class sees how it splits. How Eureka Case works →